What makes a great sandwich?

a close up photo of a cut sandwich with layers of meat and cheese and pickles

What defines a sandwich? Is a hot dog a sandwich? A taco? Bao? Where do you draw the line?

The UK office worker seemingly lives off pre-packaged sandwiches and the United States has eateries devoted to freshly prepared hot sandwiches so why does Australia seem to cling to its toasties. Thankfully, the tide is changing. 

More and more sandwich joints are opening around town offering freshly made hot or cold sandwiches that will leave one very satisfied, if not in need of several napkins to wipe their face clean. 
Body positioning is important to spill it all down the front of you, ergo the Philly stance.

Classics are classic for good reason. 
*pan bagnat – make ahead, oil soaks into bread a little so doesn’t dry out (salade niçoise but in sandwich form – olive, egg, tuna etc)
*banh mi – balance of flavours and texture, chilli punch, fresh salad, not heavy but satisfying
*finger sandwiches – look fancy with the extra effort trimming edges, not over-filled so easy/clean to eat while standing with a glass of champagne in one hand
*BLT – balance salt crispy bacon, creamy mayo, sweet acidic tomato, lettuce vegetal freshness
*NYC bagel – cured salmon, cream cheese schmear = cultural ties but also delicious. Richness of filling vs chewy ubiquitous bagel
*chip butty – hot chips in buttered white roll – carb on carb delight

Do you have a favourite sandwich or, conversely, something that should never be seen between two pieces of bread? From my childhood days, I recall my mother enjoying an apricot jam and cheddar cheese sandwich. No judgement here.

photo of a crumbed food, lettuce in a bun like a burger

I posit the following as a template for a good sandwich:
– Balance of flavours and textures is crucial not only from a construction point of view but also a taste perspective
– Season your ingredients like you would anything else
– Consider the vehicle – is this bread/roll/carb appropriate for the intended filling?
– Don’t forget the fundamental law that a sandwich made for you by a loved one will always taste better than if you make it yourself
– What’s your mood? This I believe above all will lead towards your perfect sandwich.

Listen to my chat with Lisa Leong on ABC Radio 774 as we chat what makes a great sandwich.

More blogs

From Miso to Marmalade: The  Fridge Staples That Prove Themselves Time and Again

From Miso to Marmalade: The  Fridge Staples That Prove Themselves Time and Again

We live in a small apartment with a very small kitchen, so I run a tight ship. Anything that earns space in there has to punch above its weight. Products have to prove themselves. If they don’t earn their keep, they’re out.

Marmalade Loaf

Marmalade Loaf

This is a hug in the shape of a loaf tin, reassuring in only the way an old-school reliable pantry cake can be. I say pantry cake because mostly I have all the ingredients in the pantry, even if that is a set of drawers in my small, city apartment.

Real Food, Real Kitchen, Real People

Real Food, Real Kitchen, Real People

Last weekend I gathered a handful of friends at someone’s house and we cooked together. Not a dinner party where one person does the work and everyone else arrives with a bottle. Not a formal class in a commercial kitchen. Just a group of curious eaters in a real home…

FREE RANGING FOODIE

© Copyright Amanda Kennedy 2025